Checked elsewhere / Sources

RMIT ABC Fact Check

RMIT ABC Fact Check was a partnership between RMIT University and the Australian Broadcasting Corporation.

Andrew Wilkie, Independent federal MP

“A series of Australian governments that are guilty of crimes against humanity for forcibly transferring asylum seekers to a third country and detaining them indefinitely without trial.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Untested

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Mr Wilkie's claim is an allegation of criminal conduct that is untested in a court of law. A number of communiques calling for Australian government officials to be investigated for crimes against humanity, as defined b…

Checked by RMIT ABC Fact Check22 Feb 2019Australia
Chris Bowen, Shadow Treasurer

“Home ownership rates for young people aged 25-34 have spiralled downwards in recent years from 60 per cent to 48 per cent”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: In the ballpark

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Mr Bowen's claim is in the ballpark. What counts as "recent" is debatable, but given the typical pace of change in the housing market, Fact Check has assessed the last ten years of ownership rates. None of these rates m…

Peter Dutton, Minister for Home Affairs

“Labor's proposal is to dismantle offshore detention [and will] essentially give the ability for two doctors — as has been pointed out, doctors including Dr Brown, Bob Brown, and Dr Richard Di Natale — potentially can provide the advice.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Drawing a long bow

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Mr Dutton is drawing a long bow. According to the proposals, in order to be able to advise on the transfer of refugees to Australia for medical treatment, a doctor would first need to be registered — neither Mr Brown no…

Tanya Plibersek, Deputy Opposition Leader

“Labor has more than double the number of women the Liberals have in the Parliament and about twice the number of women on our front bench ...”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Checks out

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Yes, Ms Plibersek's claim checks out, but there's more to it. There are more than twice the number of Labor women in Parliament than there are Liberal women, in both raw numbers (44 vs 19) and proportional terms (46.3 p…

Checked by RMIT ABC Fact Check12 Dec 2018Australia
Lidia Thorpe, Former Greens member for the seat Victorian state seat of Northcote

“It has been nearly a decade since Kevin Rudd's apology, yet child removal rates have increased by 400 per cent.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Yes, but more to it

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Ms Thorpe's claim doesn't check out. Data is not collected on the rate of all child removals. Given the lack of data, experts told Fact Check that the rate of admissions to out-of-home care collected by the Australian I…

Andrew Leigh, Shadow assistant treasurer

“We have net debt more than doubling since the Liberals came to office. It's just hit a record high, some $350 billion.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Yes, but more to it

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Yes, Dr Leigh's claim is correct, but there's more to it. The Government's monthly financial statements show net debt has doubled over the Coalition's two terms in government — from $174.6 billion in September 2013, whe…

Michael O'Brien, Victorian Shadow Treasurer

“... Victoria is the highest taxed state in the country under Daniel Andrews and Labor, with taxes rising by 35 per cent in just the last four years.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Yes, but more to it

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Yes Mr O'Brien is correct, but there's more to it. The state tax take has, in nominal terms, increased by about 35 per cent over four years, underpinned by strong collections of stamp duty, payroll, land and motor vehic…

Asher Judah, Liberal Party candidate

“There has been a 58 per cent increase in crime in Bentleigh since the election of the Labor Government in 2014”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: More to the story

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: There's more to the story than Mr Judah's claim suggests. Mr Judah and the Liberals have been driving their campaign truck adorned with crime statistics across the Bentleigh electorate, including the suburbs of Bentleig…

Edward O'Donohue, Victorian opposition police spokesman

“Frontline police numbers have fallen under Labor with Police Association figures showing there are now 190 fewer uniform officers than in 2013 despite Victoria's population increasing by over half a million.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Misleading

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Mr O'Donohue's claim is misleading. The figure he cites covers substantially more than the period Labor has been in office, so cannot be used to assess the record of just one government. There is also no agreed definiti…

Kelly O'Dwyer, Minister for Jobs and Industrial Relations

“Over the last 10 years, we've actually seen wages increase by around 30 per cent and inflation increase by around 20 per cent. Certainly, wages haven't grown as fast as people might like, but wages have grown steadily over that period of time.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Not the full story

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Ms O'Dwyer's claim is not the full story. She is entitled to claim that wages have grown, in nominal terms, by about 30 per cent over a decade, outstripping inflation of about 20 per cent over the same period. However, …