Checked elsewhere

Checks published by other fact-checking organisations. We did not do these checks. Each one names who did, shows their rating in their own words, and links to their full article.

Their rating
Michael O'Brien, Victorian Shadow Treasurer

“... Victoria is the highest taxed state in the country under Daniel Andrews and Labor, with taxes rising by 35 per cent in just the last four years.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Yes, but more to it

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Yes Mr O'Brien is correct, but there's more to it. The state tax take has, in nominal terms, increased by about 35 per cent over four years, underpinned by strong collections of stamp duty, payroll, land and motor vehic…

Asher Judah, Liberal Party candidate

“There has been a 58 per cent increase in crime in Bentleigh since the election of the Labor Government in 2014”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: More to the story

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: There's more to the story than Mr Judah's claim suggests. Mr Judah and the Liberals have been driving their campaign truck adorned with crime statistics across the Bentleigh electorate, including the suburbs of Bentleig…

Edward O'Donohue, Victorian opposition police spokesman

“Frontline police numbers have fallen under Labor with Police Association figures showing there are now 190 fewer uniform officers than in 2013 despite Victoria's population increasing by over half a million.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Misleading

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Mr O'Donohue's claim is misleading. The figure he cites covers substantially more than the period Labor has been in office, so cannot be used to assess the record of just one government. There is also no agreed definiti…

Kelly O'Dwyer, Minister for Jobs and Industrial Relations

“Over the last 10 years, we've actually seen wages increase by around 30 per cent and inflation increase by around 20 per cent. Certainly, wages haven't grown as fast as people might like, but wages have grown steadily over that period of time.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Not the full story

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Ms O'Dwyer's claim is not the full story. She is entitled to claim that wages have grown, in nominal terms, by about 30 per cent over a decade, outstripping inflation of about 20 per cent over the same period. However, …

Bill Shorten, Opposition Leader

“The Government cut funding by $1.2 billion from aged care in Scott Morrison's first budget as treasurer”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Misleading

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Mr Shorten's claim is misleading. In Mr Morrison's first year as federal treasurer — that is, 2016-17 — total Commonwealth funding for aged care (excluding the pension and other forms of income support for seniors, but …

Matt Canavan, Coalition Senator for Queensland

“[The proposed changes to Queensland's abortion laws] would be some of the most radical and extreme legislation of abortions in the world, and it would allow, effectively … unrestricted abortions beyond 22 weeks.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Baseless

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Senator Canavan's claim is baseless. Experts told Fact Check that the bill before Parliament contained clear restrictions on abortions after 22 weeks' gestation. While abortions would be available on request up to 22 we…

Scott Morrison, Prime Minister

“The gender pay gap has fallen from 17.2 per cent to 14.5 per cent under the policies of our government.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Overreach

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Mr Morrison's claim is overreach. His numbers check out, although they differ slightly to those from the government agency officially tasked with publishing the gender pay gap. However, they oversimplify what has happen…

Mathias Cormann, Special Minister of State

“It is a matter of history that incumbent governments find it nigh on impossible to win seats off an opposition at a by-election. For the last 100 years or so no government, of either political persuasion, has won a seat off an opposition at a by-election.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Correct

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Senator Cormann is correct. The last time an opposition lost a seat to a government at a by-election was in 1920 — almost 100 years ago. The previous MP in that by-election, Hugh Mahon, remains the only member in the hi…

Chris Del Mar, Professor of Public Health at Bond University

“Your chances of getting the flu after a vaccination are only decreased by 1 to 2 per cent”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Misleading

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Professor Del Mar's claim is misleading. The source of Professor Del Mar's claim is a systematic review of studies measuring the efficacy of flu vaccine in preventing the flu in healthy adults. That review found the flu…

Susan Anderson, World Vision policy and advocacy director

“This year's budget is the fifth year in a row that the Australian Government has cut Australian aid.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Correct

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Ms Anderson's claim is correct. Across the five financial years from 2014-15 to 2018-19, the aid budget has been cut twice in nominal terms. And while data from the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade shows that nom…

Checked by RMIT ABC Fact Check25 Apr 2018Australia
Bill Shorten, Opposition Leader

“It is true that posthumously promoting Monash to field marshal in this centenary year would be a break with normal protocol." "But there are powerful precedents for such a decision.”

RMIT ABC Fact Check rated this: Yes, but more to it

RMIT ABC Fact Check says: Mr Shorten's claim doesn't check out. In support of his argument, Mr Shorten cited three examples of men whose promotions, he claimed, had broken with protocol: Sir Thomas Blamey, Prince Philip, and General George Washi…